Management Information

Identifying Candidates for Leadership


A critical task in the succession planning process of any organization is identifying candidates. Traditionally, candidates have been identified based on past performance. While this seems logical, it is problematic in practice.

Past performance always measures success in a lower-level position. What is needed in succession planning is a system to identify potential for success in a future higher-level position. The best predictive model I have found is the Leadership Pipeline Model by Charan, Drotter, and Noel.

The Leadership Pipeline provides a model that describes the skills, time applications, and values required to succeed at different levels in the organization. While most leadership models and theories describe characteristics of leaders in general, the Leadership Pipeline describes specific criteria for success in transitioning from one level to the next.

The Leadership Pipeline Model helps us to see the importance of identifying candidates for positions throughout the entire organization. The pipeline must be continuously filled with leaders who have been identified for development for the next higher level. A pipeline clog at one level will clearly harm leadership development and succession throughout the entire organization. What is needed is a carefully monitored system for developing in-house talent from front-line supervisors to CEOs.

At GE and Citicorp, two companies using the Leadership Pipeline Model, leadership passages from one level to the next are seen as "turns" in the leadership pipeline. These turns (or passages) provide significant developmental experiences. If these turns are skipped the individual may not be prepared for higher-level leadership positions. The focus for development should be the lack of critical skills and values for the next higher level, not past performance.

I am often asked "Is it better to recruit from outside the organization or to develop leaders from within?" The safe, but rather uninsightful answer is, "It depends."

Recruiting from outside the organization makes sense when a major change in corporate culture or direction is needed. But, I would caution about the over-dependence on outside recruiting of leaders. Desperate attempts to recruit leaders from outside the organization suggest an inadequate leadership pipeline.

Recruiting leaders from the outside of the organization can be very expensive. As we all know, there is a talent shortage in the marketplace. This can lead to paying high premiums (or even outright price wars) for promising talent.

The Leadership Pipeline Model offers a common language (terminology) and specific criteria for what to look for in leaders at the next higher level. The Model provides a description of the skills, time applications, and values required of leaders at each successive level. This criteria is critical not only for identifying candidates but also for their subsequent development.

The key to identifying candidates for higher levels of responsibility is to predict their potential to succeed in attaining and using the skills, time applications, and values of the next higher level. Past performance is often a poor predictor of future success. Remember that the skills, time applications, and values of each successive level of leadership are dramatically different.

The challenge in succession planning and identifying candidates is making sure people are assigned to a level that is appropriate for them. The challenge is complicated by the fact that people change (hopefully for the better) over time. An appropriate position for someone today may not be appropriate three years from now.

Identifying candidates for the organization's future leadership positions is a critical task. Do you have a system for identifying candidates that considers not only their current skills, but also their willingness to adopt new work values and time applications?

Dr. Mike Beitler is the author of "Strategic Organizational Change." Get a free 7-part mini-course and learn more about the book at http://www.strategic-organizational-change.com/


MORE RESOURCES:

HRmagazine.co.uk

News Analysis: The Implications Of Oracle's Acquisition Of Taleo
Forbes
On February 9th, Oracle announced its intention to acquire Dublin, CA based Taleo for $1.9B. Taleo is a cloud based talent management software provider with 5000 customers and 1400 employees. Key take aways to consider: Moves by SAP and Oracle intend ...
Oracle buying Taleo for $1.9 billion, cloud war brewsReuters
Roll up, roll up! Oracle digest TaleoZDNet (blog)
Oracle acquires talent management firm TaleoHRmagazine.co.uk
ReadWriteWeb -Financial Times -MarketWatch (press release)
all 453 news articles »


Yeung Says Fidelity Fund Managers Favor China Stocks
Washington Post
10 (Bloomberg) -- Catherine Yeung, an investment director at Fidelity Investment Management Ltd. in Hong Kong, talks about Asian stocks and bonds. Warren Buffett, the billionaire chairman of Berkshire Hathaway Inc., said low interest rates and ...

and more »


Health Management Associates, Inc. to Present at the Leerink Swan 2012 Global ...
MarketWatch (press release)
NAPLES, Fla., Feb 09, 2012 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- Health Management Associates, Inc. /quotes/zigman/229077/quotes/nls/hma HMA -2.71% announced today that its management will present at the Leerink Swan 2012 Global Healthcare Conference to be held February ...
Quality Systems, Inc. to Present at Leerink Swann 2012 Global Healthcare ...EON: Enhanced Online News (press release)

all 179 news articles »


New President to Pohjola Asset Management Limited
Reuters
Pohjola Bank plc STOCK EXCHANGE RELEASE 10 February 2012, 9.30 am EET New President to Pohjola Asset Management Limited Pohjola Asset Management Limited, a subsidiary of Pohjola Bank plc, is appointing a new President: Mr Karri Alameri (48), ...

and more »


Shawmut Property Management Proudly Announces Three New Condominium Management ...
MarketWatch (press release)
9, 2012 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Shawmut Property Management, LLC ( www.shawmutpropertymanagement.com ), a full-service condominium management company that services Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Maine, today announced that it has entered into new ...

and more »


York Capital Management Funds Mostly Post Gains In Jan - Letter
Wall Street Journal
NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Hedge fund manager York Capital Management said most of its funds posted gains in January, though its $470 million Asian Opportunities Fund declined by a minor 0.4%, according to an investor letter. The letter didn't detail how ...

and more »


Edgewood Management Holdings in 4th Quarter: 13F Alert
Bloomberg
The following is an analysis of Edgewood Management LLC as of Dec. 31, according to a filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission on Feb. 9. Top Positions by Market Value Company Name Ticker Market Value Current Change (USD $) Position In ...

and more »


NFL time-management debates go into overtime
San Francisco Chronicle (blog)
The strategy itself has become a fashionable, one-size-fits-all piece of time management. But it didn't match the Giants' needs and won't cover anyone's posterior when it backfires. A team takes a huge risk by ordering the offense to play defensive ...

and more »


Petrobras Shakes Up Management As New Chief Executive Is Named
Wall Street Journal
BR), on Thursday unveiled a shake-up of its most senior managers, coinciding with the appointment of a new chief executive. Jose Miranda Formigli Filho was named as head of exploration and production, taking over full responsibility for the company's ...

and more »


Och-Ziff Capital 4Q Net Loss Widens To $137 Million
Wall Street Journal
By Amy Or Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--Hedge fund manager Och-Ziff Capital Management Group LLC's (OZM) fourth-quarter net loss widened on lower incentive income resulting from negative returns experienced by most of the company's funds ...
Och-Ziff Capital Management Group LLC Reports 2011 Fourth Quarter and Full ...MarketWatch (press release)
Och-Ziff profit off as performance fees shrunkReuters
Och-Ziff Net Income Drops 94% as Performance Fees DeclineBloomberg

all 15 news articles »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006